Thoughts on Jamie’s Dream School

• Post

• 22 March 2011

• Posted by Alastair Campbell

• 9

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwQBJIb45vU

1 minute(s) read

Recent Posts

Europe needs to get real on defence; Britain needs to get real on Europe

13 February 2025

Why we should be upgrading not downgrading language teaching in schools across the UK

9 November 2024

Lessons from the rise and fall, and most importantly the healing, of Bradley Wiggins. Great cyclist. Great guy. Who just made me shed a tear …

13 August 2024

These bloody opinion polls are now the biggest threat to a decent Labour majority that allows them to get stuff done

21 June 2024

9 responses to “Thoughts on Jamie’s Dream School”

1. don’t think this was as related to reality as the kids to cooks enterprise was…
   and that is mainly down to the impossibility of getting a bell curve of typical students. – but you faired better than many expected – and its not a job that drew me in any way…three siblings did…. I am the youngest but I look twenty years younger than all of them

   Reply

2. To be 100% honest, I though it was a waste of your talent. Getting an entire room full of, essentially, problem kids to listen was never going to be easy or particularly fruitful… It looked like a seriously hard job, but I respect you for doing it.
   Keep up the good work on the charities.

   Reply

3. hi alastair,

   i am listening to your broadcast on lbc as i type, (ive always been a fan of yours)….has jamie oliver any thoughts on becoming a politician do u know? he is a great bloke as well and the causes he has fought for have made him an inspiration to many people….or does he basically stay apolitical in order not to pigeon-hole himself with one political party?

   Reply

4. On the contrary: If Al and the other celebs had not participated the audience would have been minimal. Any airing of the “inadequate” results of the education system is valuable. These kids have fallen through every safety net erected, despite the vastly greater resources put into education over the last ten years. The frustration felt by overworked teachers can be felt by us all watching these shows. As Al says, the debate has been broadened as a result. The celebs were on a hiding to nothing and are to be congratulated on their partipation.

   Reply

5. making it a reality TV show, meant we had the usual pantomime of performers – so it’s not really reality at all. The kids were performing for the camera, so I could not watch more than 2 eps. I think you and most of the other ‘teachers’ were fantastic – engaging and genuine. People should stick to what they know – Jamie was bloody marvelous on his school dinner programme. I think he should tackle diet & nutrition beyond schools to beat disease and illnesses.

   Reply

6. I caught up with it on Youtube and it was very interesting and watchable. I thought you did a great job in demonstrating that the gap between politicians and young students is not as big as it sometimes seems. I mean, these were ‘challenging’ students, and you were really able to connect with them and encourage them. Though, I could envisage quite a few politicians (especially Tory ones) having a hard time connecting with them. It was really watchable because it was clearly a challenge for you, the teachers, as well as the students. I think you all did well – Even David Starkey was connecting with them. Agree with you that it probably won’t have any lasting effect on education, but it’s definitely been a positive program for society in general.

   Reply

7. Fair enough, I accept your point, it just felt a bit like watching a bunch of teenagers playing up for a couple of hours. Not my thing.
   I would have preferred to see some AC original programming… Hopefully he’ll have more in the pipeline.

   Reply

8. I work as a teacher in a socio-economically deprived area and thought the program really highlights the demands of teaching in an inspiring way. I was under the misguided thoughts it was going to be a “look how good we are all at teaching and how teachers need to be” but it was not at all. Unfortunately there are struggles like seen in the program in classes all the time and I think it is extremely important to gain some kind of rapport with your kids rather than the old traditionalist view of I am a teacher you must respect me. Our society has changed and students know that we are accountable, whether this is good or bad is another matter but we have to deal with it. If the kids know that you are really interested in them as individuals it goes some way into engaging them.

   Reply

9. I’m a bit torn between thinking the programme has exploited the participants and/or whether it has helped them. Do you think in general it has been positive for them, Alastair?

   Reply